ICE Reclassifies Common Form I-9 Errors As Substantive Violations

April 21, 2026

What's New

On March 16, 2026, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) revised its Form I-9 Inspection Fact Sheet, changing how certain Form I-9 errors are classified. Historically, many routine minor errors, e.g., forgetting to insert a date, were treated as technical or procedural violations, giving employers a 10-business-day opportunity to correct them after receiving a Notice of Inspection. The updated Fact Sheet narrows that correction window by reclassifying a number of common errors as substantive violations subject to immediate civil penalties.

What It Means

Technical I-9 errors that HR teams have long viewed as fixable during an audit—such as missing dates, incomplete certifications, or certain preparer/translator omissions—may now result in fines without an opportunity to cure. ICE’s revised framework emphasizes that the Form I-9 must be complete and compliant on its face at the time of inspection, even where employers acted in good faith or retained supporting documentation. This change increases audit risk and limits the effectiveness of post-inspection remediation.

What You Should Do

Employers should conduct proactive I-9 self-audits, correct any deficiencies discovered as soon as possible, and reinforce training for HR and onboarding personnel. Employers should also make sure they are adequately prepared for an I-9 audit.

RELATED CONTENT

Add

Data pager
Data pager
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... Page size: 5 10 20 50 Change page size 61 items in 13 pages

Show all 61

INA-IRCA: Employment Eligibility and Nondiscrimination

Jun 17, 2025 – A high level summary of the employment eligibility and nondiscrimination requirements on the Immigration and Nationality Act and the Immigration Reform and Control Act.

DOJ Releases Fact Sheet on Anti-Discrimination Rights of Green Card Holders

Dec 11, 2024 – The Justice Department’s Immigrant and Employee Rights Section published a Fact Sheet that outlines the protections afforded green card holders against discrimination in the workplace.

CWC's Guide to ICE I-9 Audits and Workplace Raids

Apr 1, 2025 – In light of the Trump Administration’s focus on immigration enforcement, we’ve updated our guide to I-9 audits and workplace raids by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

USCIS Finalizes Rules Revamping H-1B Lottery System and Increasing Visa Fees

Feb 7, 2024 – In its continuing effort to make the H-1B visa selection process more efficient and less prone to fraud, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services agency has issued two new rules designed to achieve those objectives.

CWC's Outline of the Form I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification Process

Feb 12, 2025 – This Form I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification Process resource provides information on how to complete Form I-9 and answers frequently asked questions.

Subscribe to CWC's Updates and Events

CLICK TO SIGN UP

New Tab

Resources

Our library of sources helping you understand and manage your workplace requirements and risks.

Data Center

Metrics and dashboards guiding you to make statistics and research-driven decisions.

Events

Learn and network at events focused on compliance policy, practice, and strategy.

Diversance Connect

Helping members find and connect with thousands of outreach and recruitment sources.